"Love Spell Gone Wrong" [F4F Version] 

by littlemissjazz 

_______________ 


***Script Starts Here
 
 
[Sound of a knock on the door] [Sound of the door opening with a creak] 


Man #1: Hey. Is this a bad time? [The listener replies] Okay, good. I had asked because, you know...you’ve got your little spellbook and ingredients out. I can see them on the table back there. (lightly chuckles as the listener blushes) You don’t have to look so embarrassed about it. I know that you’re a witch. You were quite open about that fact when we first met. 

I can’t believe that was only a few months ago. I still remember it like it was yesterday; us bumping into each other downstairs in the laundry room and embarrassingly enough, I made you drop your basket of clothes and had to pick up your underwear. Nice taste in bras, I must say. (laughs) Hey, c’mon, don’t hit me! Just trying to break the ice here. I’m trying to lighten the mood for what…(sighs deeply) for what I’m about to say. 

(chuckles nervously) God...now that I’m here, I realize that this will be way harder than I thought. I’ve been rehearsing this in my head and in the mirror so many times and I… What the **** am I saying? Ignore what I just said. There’s something wrong with me today. Something...weird. I-I can’t place it, but...I know it has to do with you. 

(sighs, exasperated) Okay. Look, here’s the deal. Do you remember when you came to my door a couple weeks ago with that little pink bottle? The one you said I should put in my tea to make it sweeter? [The listener replies] Yeah, that one. This was after we had been talking for a few months. 

So I did what you said and you were right; it did make the tea sweeter. But then overtime, things started to get...weird. Like I can’t stop thinking about you. No matter what I do throughout the days–whether I work, go to the gym, eat, sleep–I can’t get you off my mind. And the thing is I barely sleep anymore. If I do, my dreams are plagued by thoughts of you. Thoughts of your glossy hair, your gorgeous face, your pretty eyes, your soft, supple lips...and other things. 

[The listener asks you a question] What are those other things? *flustered* Well...i-it...it’s not important! The point is that I feel like I’m drawn to you. It’s not like some kind of crush either. It’s like...an obsession. An addiction. I’m addicted to you. That’s what I rushed over here–to tell you. I felt as if I didn’t then I’d drive myself insane keeping it from you. And I’m not sure if it’s that little bottle you gave me or if it’s just my crush growing to alarming heights, but...I know how I feel about you. Every time I see you, I get the sudden urge to grab you and kiss you and never let you go. I just want to hold you until I’m so sure that you know exactly how I feel about you. You’re the first thing that I think about when I wake up and the last thing I think about at night. 

(sighs) I guess...what I’m trying to tell you is….I really, really like you. No, not just like you. I...I actually...I lo– 


 [Sound of door opening & closing with a creal] 


Man #2: Oh. Sorry. The door was just unlocked and I thought that… [to Man #1] What the hell are you doing here? 


Man #1: [to Man #2] I could be asking you the same thing. Do you know her? [to listener] ]Do you know him? 


Man #2: Yeah, I know her. We’ve been talking to each other for a couple weeks now. I knew of her before because I’ve seen her around the apartment complex. Though she was pretty cute, but kinda quiet and we never really spoke. Never really gave her much thought...until now, at least. 


Man #1: [To listener] What is he talking about? You’ve been talking to my roommate for weeks now? While you’ve been talking to me? [A slight pause] *irritated* Yes, he’s my roommate. He’s been my roommate for over a year now. 


Man #2: Wait, wait...you’ve been talking to her too? I had just asked for her number after I drank that little pink bottle you had in the kitchen. I thought it was something to put in my water to make it taste like fruit, but– 


Man #1: Wait...what did you say? Something about that little bottle in the kitchen? 


Man #2: Yeah...you had said I could have a bit because it was sweet, so I did and I’ve been feeling really weird all of the sudden. [To listener] Like I can’t stop thinking about you. You’re always on my mind. I just wanna hold you and kiss you and- 


Man #1: [to Man #2] Hold that thought, man. [to listener] *in a growly, angered tone* You. You’ve got a lot of explaining to do and I suggest you do it now. What the hell is going on here? You’ve been talking to the both of us at the same time? And that little bottle you gave me...what the hell was in that? Some kind of drug? 


Man #2: [A slight pause as the listener explains] A love potion? [A slight pause] *shook* What do you mean? You’re...you’re a what? A witch? ****...so this entire time I’ve been crushing on a witch? 


Man #1: That’s not even the disturbing part. That little bottle wasn’t something for beverages at all. You gave that love potion to me for a reason. [A slight pause as the listener explains] Hold up, hold up...I know what the ****’s going on here. No, no, you don’t have to explain anymore. You gave me that love potion so I’d fall in love with you but then it backfired because my roommate drank some of it too. And now here he is. 


Man #2: Yes...here I am. I only drank a little bit, and yet it still worked on me. So you gave that potion to us on purpose? Why in the world would you do something like that? [A slight pause as the listener talks herself down] *softly* Hey, don’t you dare talk about yourself like that. You are not a shy, pathetic, stupid little witch. Shy, yes. Not you are not pathetic or stupid. You were just lonely. Why, I can’t understand because you’re so ******* cute. 


Man #1: [To Man #2] Hey, don’t try to butter her up! This is some serious shit! She took advantage of us both! [To listener when she protests] (dryly scoffs) Oh, no? Then how do you explain us being here? That damn potion gave us feelings that aren’t natural...Well, not all of them anyway. We’re here because we’re addicted to you. And it’s all your ******* fault. 


Man #2: Well, I wouldn’t be that harsh with you, but he’s right. You could’ve just talked to either of us without the potion. More so him than me since the potion was intended for him. Hell, I probably shouldn’t even be here. [The listener tells you no] No? You want me to stay? 


Man #1: *bitterly* For what? So you can have both of us? 


Man #2: Wait a second, bro…. That’s actually not a bad idea. Why don’t we both stay and give this cute little witch just exactly what she signed up for? 


Man #1: Oh...oh. (chuckles sneakily) I think I like that idea. I like that idea ~a lot. [To the listener who looks alarmed] Don’t look so afraid now, sweetheart. We’re both here for a reason. You caused this and now you’re going to pay the consequences. Every single thing I’ve been fantasizing I’m going to do to you right now with him watching. And you’re going to take it. You know why? Because you deserve it. 


Man #2: (chuckles softly) Don’t back away from us, baby girl. We’re not going to hurt you. All we’re going to do is show you just exactly how much we want you. How much we crave you. Don’t you want that, baby? Don’t you want us to make you feel good? To get exactly what you wanted? 


Man #1: Apologies didn’t work before and they won’t work now. You can’t run away from this. And even if you did, we wouldn’t let you go. Now get your ass over here. Now gonna listen, hm? Maybe you’ll listen if I (grunts) grab you by your waist and pin you to me. *in a rough, growly tone* Stop squirming. If you wanted me to let you go, you would’ve used those witchy powers of yours to get me off you a long time ago. You can’t tell me you don’t enjoy this. You being pinned to my body with your arms trapped under mine, don’t you? Lie to me again and I swear, I’ll pull you over my lap and spanking that ass myself. 


Man #2: (chuckles) I think she’d like that. Would you like that, baby? Would you like him to bend you over your lap and spank that pretty little ass until it’s red? Maybe I’ll plunge my fingers into that ***** of yours? Don’t lie to me either, girl. [Listener nods] Good girl. I think you like being called that. You wanna be our good girl tonight, don’t you? 


Man #1: [Listener nods] Good girl, being so obedient. Now give me those ******* lips. [Rough kissing sounds in between dialogue] Do you have any idea how long I’ve been wanting to do this? ******* kiss you while I run my hands down your body and grab that ass of yours? I bet you’ve been wanting for me to do this too, right? That’s why you did that little spell bullshit on me. 


Man #2: Hey, don’t hog her up. I want some of those lips too. Come here, gorgeous. [Soft kissing sounds in between dialogue] ****, you taste so good! And you feel so good. Can you feel how hard I am? Can you feel my **** pressing up against your back? That’s all for you. You wouldn’t even need a stupid spell or a potion to help with that if I would’ve gotten you alone sooner. 


Man #1: You’re wearing way too many ******* clothes. Help me get these off her. [Rustling of clothes SFX]


Man #2: (chuckles) With pleasure. You would like us to strip you, baby? [The listener agrees] Good. Only if you want us too. 


Man #1: Of course, she wants us too. Look at her. Look at how hard she’s breathing; how flushed she is. She can barely contain herself. You’re just aching for us to strip of your clothes, throw you down and take that ******* ***** any way we want, aren’t you? Mmm, I know you are, baby. But first you gotta work for it. 


Man #2: That I have to agree with. (scoffs playfully) What? You think we were just going to give you these dicks right off the bat? No, no, nooo, baby girl. We may adore you, but we’re not that generous and you’re too greedy. You need to work for it. [a slight pause as she tells them she wants to see both of their cocks] You want to see both? 
 
 
Man #1: ****! I can’t lie and say that hearing that doesn’t get rock hard hearing that. Say the magic word, baby. [Listener says please] Good girl. 
 
 
 Man #2: Well, if you’re okay with it, we won’t keep you waiting. 
 
 
[Zipper sounds as both unzip their trousers] 
 
 
Man #1: Well, here we are, gorgeous. Out, hard and throbbing in the open. So are you going to do something with them or just stare at them? (hisses sharply) You surely take charge. Feeling your hand wrapped around my **** like that… 
 
 
Man #2: Yeah? You like me stroking my **** against those luscious ****? Mmm, yes...turn your head and open your mouth like that while I (moans loudly) slide in and out. ****, I can feel the back of your throat! [moaning improv] 


Man #1: Oh, God, yes, that’s...that’s so ******* good! Yes, you like me tapping the head against your tongue like that? Mmm, you like this ****, don’t you? Yeah, you like taking my shaft down that pretty throat? Yes, take it, you little slut. [grunting & groaning as he slowly yet roughly ***** her face] 
 
 
Man #2: I want some of that too. Turn your head and take me deep into your throat. (groans softly) Yes, that’s it, baby! Run your tongue down the base just like that. (grunts) Mmm, ****, you’re a natural! 


Man #1: Let me just (grunts) grip that hair and thrust my **** in and out of that pretty throat. Look up at me while I **** that pretty face of yours. You ******* deserve this shit. You know what to do with this dick, don’t you? [grunting & groaning as he slowly yet roughly ***** her face as well] 


Man #2: (moaning loudly) God! You can’t even fit your entire hand around me. Let me help you then, baby. I’ll just (grunts) thrust in and out of your hand. Does it feel good pleasing two cocks at the same time? 
 
 
[moaning & dirty talk improv as she blows & strokes both of you] 
 
 
Man #1: (grunting) ****...****! Enough of this. I’m not going to cum into your hand. (chuckles softly) Oh...so you want me to cum, huh? Alright, baby, but not in your hand. I wanna cum all over that pretty face and in that mouth. Yes, take that shit! You know how to work this ****, don’t you? DON’T YOU? 
 
 
Man #2: ****! ****, girl, yes! I’m gonna cum, baby! I’m gonna cum all over your gorgeous face. Stick out your tongue. God, yes, please! Keep stroking me just like that! 
 
 
[Moaning & dirty talk improv as you both climax] 


Man #2: [Heavy breathing] ****...oh, wow. That was phenomenal. 


Man #1: (sighs in satisfaction) I agree. You deserve an award for that. Here, stand up, baby. I’m not done with you yet. Not until I get my tongue up inside that sweet little ***** and make you cum all over my face. 


Man #2: You mean ~our faces. [To listener] What, you thought I was just gonna sit back and watch? No, I don’t roll that way, baby. I’ve been waiting for weeks to taste you. So many sleepless nights of dreaming of my face between your thighs have finally led me here. And you’re going to love every second of it. 


Man #1: *in a demanding, rough tone* Lay down. Now spread your ******* legs. Wider. Now spread open those lips. You ******* heard me. Don’t wanna listen? Turn the **** over. That’s what you get for not listening to me. And for this potion witch shit. You pull some shit like this on us again, you’ll get more of these, you understand? Huh? 


Man #2: Mmm, I think she likes it, man. Look how she keeps squirming around in your lap. [Spank!] *sheepish* Sorry, baby. I just had to get a feel of that ass jiggling against my hand too. [To Man #1] Maybe we should reward her for taking her punishment so well? You think? 


Man #1: *thinking* Mmm...eh, what the hell. I’m game. [To listener] Turn that ass over and spread your legs again. ****...you just spread your ***** without us even telling you to. You really want this, don’t you, you needy little slut? 


Man #2: ****, the way you spread yourself wide and look straight into our eyes like that...**** this. I need to taste you right now, baby. Let me just ditch this shirt first. You ready, girl? Because I’m ******* drooling just at the thought of tasting you. [Cunnlingus improv] God! You’re so wet. Is that all for me? Really, kitten? (laughs lightly) And you taste so ******* good. 


Man #1: [To Man #2] Hold up, bro. Don’t just assume all that is for you. Scoot over. [Cunnlingus improv] **** me, you do taste good! I thought he was just exaggerating, but...shit! I need more. I need to taste more of you. [Cunnlingus improv sounds con.] God, you’re so wet. You’re practically soaking my face. 


Man #2: [Cunnlingus improv con.] Do you like that, girl? You like the way my tongue flicks across that needy little clit? How about how I nibble at your lips? [Wet nibbling sounds] You like that, hm? [Cunnlingus improv between dialogue] That’s it, moan for me. Say my name. God, it feels amazing to know I’m the one making you like this. 


Man #1: (chuckles) You can’t even contain yourself. You’re a squirming, needy little mess. You’re just begging to cum all over our faces, aren’t you? Can you feel how hard I am? Can you feel my **** pressed up against your thighs? So big...and thick...and hot? 
 
 
[Cunnlingus & dirty talk improv] 


Man #1: (growls softly) You’re gonna cum, aren’t you? I can feel your thighs starting to shake and those walls clenching around my tongue. 


Man #2: Cum for us, baby. You wanna be a good girl for us, right? Then cum. Cum for us right now. I can’t take much more of this. God! You taste so good! 


[Cunnlingus & dirty talk improv con. until the listener climaxes] 

 
Man #1: *growly* Enough of this shit. Get the **** up. I need to **** you right now and I’m not taking no for an answer being the fact that you caused this mess. 


Man #2: I don’t think I can take much more of this foreplay either, baby. I won’t hurt you, but I need to **** you. If I don’t, I’ll go insane. (chuckles when listener talks dirty) Such a mouth on you. Well, if it’s what the woman wants- 
 
 
Man #1: -then you’ll get it. Don’t say we didn’t warn you though. 


Man #2: Let me just lay back against the couch… (sighs) and you can straddle me with those sexy legs. 


Man #1: Now bend over. Perfect. (hisses & moans in pleasure) Does it feel good feeling me slide my **** up and down your lips? How about when I [light smacking sounds] (moans) smack it against your clit? (laughs through his moaning) You’re so cute when you’re flustered. No, no, baby girl. You don’t get what you want until you beg for it. 


Man #2: We want to hear you beg. Tell us how much you want us. How much you want our throbbing, hard, thick cocks inside of you, filling you up until you can’t even think of anything except the pleasure. Say please, darling. [ a slight pause as she begs for them to make love to her] Mmm, good girl. You get a reward for that. 


Man #1: (moaning in ecstasy) ****, ****, fuuuck, you’re so tight! And so wet! I’ve gotta be careful or I’ll bust a nut inside you way quicker than I’d like. 
 
 
Man #2: Does that feel good? I’m not hurting you? [a slight pause] Okay, good. I’m gonna start moving now. [a slight pause] You want me to just shut up and **** you, huh? (chuckles) Such bossiness. (moans in ecstasy)  
 

[Wet sounds as you begin to move] [SFX is key to a great experience lol] 

 
Man #2: Oh, ****! Yes! You’re so tight and wet around me! It’s like you’re trying to make me cum with each thrust. (grunts loudly) Oh, God, yes! Seeing you bounce on top of me like that...give me those ****. Let me hold them in my hands. [dirty talk improv w/ wet, slapping sounds con.] What’s that, baby? You want me to go faster? You want me to pound into that ***** so fast and hard, huh? 
 
 
Man #1: Yes! ****, YES! This is so damn good! Yes, throw your head back and cry out, you good little slut. Let’s see if that voice will work if I (grunts) wrap my hand around that pretty throat. Does that feel good for you? [growling & grunting sounds] OH, ****! B-Baby...did you use some kind of spell to make yourself tighter? Because nobody can be this tight! (laughs breathlessly) 
 
 
[More moaning & dirty talk improv w/ wet *** sounds cont.] 


Man #2: **** yes! Do you like this, baby? Two men ravishing your body at the same time? Two cocks filling up both of your holes? What if I just (grunts) take a fistful of your hair like that? Is that good? 
 
 
Man #1: **** yes! Choke and moan around my hand! Such a good little slut, aren’t you! Let me bend you over lower and **** you harder, like the willing little thing you are. That feel nice, my naughty girl? (growls) Mine. You’re ******* mine. You’re both of ours. 
 
 
[More dirty talk & moaning improv as wet thrusting sounds con.] 
 
 
Man #2: God! I just felt you get tighter. You’re going to cum, aren’t you? Cum for me then, baby girl. Do it! I want you to. I won’t stop pumping my **** inside of you until you cum around it. Do it! Make this **** yours. Claim it. Yes, that’s it! 
 
 
Man #1: Oh, God, I can feel it too. **** yes, take that dick. Take it and cum on it. Cum around both of our cocks. Cum like a good ******* little girl! [Moaning improv as she climaxes] Oh, ****! I feel your ***** tightening around me! God, it’s so good! I-I can’t take it. I’m going to cum soon. Do you want that, huh, girl? Do you want me to claim that ***** while he claims your ass? 
 
 
Man #2: I can’t hold on for long, gorgeous. I’m going to explode soon. Here, let me hold you tighter in my arms. Lean forward so I can kiss those lips. [Rough, passionate kissing sounds] [Moaning becomes louder & thrusting becomes more frequent] Oh...oh, ****! Baby...I-I gonna cum. You’re too ******* much for me. I...you’re gonna cum again? Really? ****, you’re insane! (laughs lightly) 


[Gradually the wet slapping sounds & moaning become faster & louder]
 
 
Man #1: Oh, ****, yes, fill her up. Cum deep inside of her. (grunts loudly) And I’ll do the same. And you’re going to take both of our loads, girl. You’re going to take every ounce of our cum in that sweet little ***** and that pretty ass of yours. Is this what you wanted? Huh? Is this what you ******* wanted? Oh, God, that’s so goddamn GOOD! [Dialogue falls into nothing but sounds of pleasure] 
 
 
[*** noises & dirty talk improv as you both get closer to climaxing] 

 
Man #2: You gonna take it? Hm? You gonna take our cum, pretty girl? Yeah? [Go ham at this part here lol] ****! ****, I’m close! Yes, cum with me, baby! Please cum with me! Oh, ****, yes! 
 
 
Man #1: (grunting in absolute ecstasy, unable to hold on anymore) God! I’m cumming too! Take it, kitten! Take all of it! Take all of me right...*******...NOW! 
 
 
[Improv as you both finally climax] [Do whatever sounds feel comfortable for the both of you right here] 
 
 
Man #1: (panting heavily) Oh...oh, my God…. (laughs) Oh, God! Wow! That was...that was...
 
 
Man #2: Amazing. (breathes heavily) That was absolutely amazing. You are something else, baby. I swear. [A slight pause] (laughs lightly) So are we? Well, I’m glad we were able to please you. Please. Kiss me. [Soft kissing sounds] 

 
Man #1: Hey, don’t be selfish. Daddy needs some sugar too. [Soft kissing sounds] (sighs) So perfect. Stop apologizing for the potion thing. It’s done now. Nobody was harmed...at least I hope not. We didn’t hurt you, did we? I know I got kinda rough with you for a while. [Listener answers] (chuckles) You liked it, huh? Well, I’ll remember that when we do this again. 
 
 
Man #2: Me too. I could get used to this. [A slight pause] Of course I want a next time, baby. Maybe not with him though. I’d prefer to **** you into oblivion without him at least once. 
 
 
Man #1: Says you, asshole! You just invited yourself in here without permission. [To the listener when she laughs at your fighting] You like us fighting over you, huh? This could definitely work out, I think. Just no more weird potions or spells, alright? I’m into freaky shit, but nothing that freaky.
 
 
Man #2: (laughs softly) Well, then I guess you could say that spell of yours was a success, hm? Come here, let us hold you and just...relax. (sighs softly) Definitely a success here. 
 
 
***Script Ends Here